House Ad
House Ad
 

Economia Gli economisti (English version)

Germany Is Not China

Storia dell'articolo

Chiudi

Questo articolo è stato pubblicato il 16 agosto 2010 alle ore 17:17.


ROTTERDAM – There is little dispute that global imbalances in trade and capital flows are at least partly to blame for the financial crisis and ensuing recession that have rocked the world economy since 2008. But not all imbalances are created equal, so it is important to weigh the consequences of individual countries’ external accounts for global economic stability and prosperity.

The conventional story of the crisis is well known: rising home prices fueled private consumption in the United States in the early 2000’s, despite tepid wage growth. Together with the widening US budget deficit, America’s current-account deficit – already large – ballooned, mirrored by bulging external surpluses in China and, as oil prices spiraled, in oil-producing countries like the United Arab Emirates.

Europe, meanwhile, looked wonderfully well balanced, at least superficially, whether one considered all 27 European Union members or the 16-member eurozone. While the US ran current-account deficits of up to 6% of GDP, the EU and the eurozone rarely had a deficit – or surplus – exceeding 1% of GDP.

In the past year, however, it has become all too clear that all this was just an illusion. Beneath the surface, huge imbalances were building up, resulting in debt-fueled real-estate booms in the euro periphery. Germany and the Netherlands ran surpluses in the range of 7% to 9% of GDP, balancing the current account for the eurozone as a whole. But, by 2006, Portugal, Spain, and Greece were running current-account deficits of 9% of GDP or more.

The China-US relationship resembles that between a mail-order company and a not-so-solvent client. The world’s most populous country is the largest foreign creditor of the US government and government-sponsored enterprises such as Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. China’s official foreign-exchange reserves of more than $2.5 trillion, stemming from double-digit current-account surpluses and capital inflows, are mostly invested in dollar-denominated bonds.

Some commentators argue that Germany plays the same role within the eurozone that China plays in Chimerica, the term coined by Niall Ferguson and Moritz Schularick to describe the symbiotic China-US economic and trade relationship. If one focuses solely on the current-account side of the balance of payments, it may look that way. In 2007, as its external surplus reached a record of 7.5% of GDP, Germany’s biggest bilateral surplus was with the US (Ђ29.5 billion), followed by Spain, France, the United Kingdom, and Italy. It ran its largest bilateral deficit (Ђ21.2 billion) with China, followed by Norway, Ireland, and Japan.

L’articolo continua sotto

Tags Correlati: 2gether | Bundesbank | Europa | Europe | Fannie Mae | Freddie Mac | Germany Is Not | Heleen Mees | Moritz Schularick | Wall Street

 

But Germany did not accumulate foreign reserves the way that China did. On the contrary, German foreign reserves actually declined between 2000 and 2008. Whereas China is a large net recipient of foreign direct investment (FDI), Germany is a large net exporter of FDI. China’s net FDI inflow totaled $94 billion in 2008, compared to Germany’s net FDI outflow of $110 billion.

Indeed, net FDI makes up about one-third of Germany’s capital account. More than half of these investments are within other EU countries, with a further 30% going to the US. According to the Bundesbank, German FDI accounts for almost six million jobs abroad. That number does not include the additional jobs resulting from increased economic activity in a region.

German’s surplus is thus less damaging than China’s, as it is used for investments that foster productivity gains, economic growth, and job creation – and that often include technology transfers that help to develop human capital.

The Chinese surplus, on the other hand, being heavily skewed towards US government bonds, primarily boosts personal consumption – a process whose apotheosis came in the early 2000’s, as the Bush administration’s tax cuts, together with cash-out home refinancing and home-equity loans, turned US sovereign debt into consumer credit. Of course, the demand generated by Chinese credit also fosters economic growth, but mostly in China, owing to booming exports to the US.

With the bulk of its baby boomers retiring in the coming decade, Germany has a valid motive to save. In view of the country’s shrinking workforce and already high capital-to-labor ratio, it is also understandable that German investors do not see many domestic investment opportunities, and instead choose to invest abroad.

It is, of course, unfortunate that German banks and pension funds lent money to debt-laden countries such as Spain, Greece, and Portugal on overly favorable terms, inflating asset bubbles that eventually had to burst. As with any creditor who makes an unwise investment, the banks and pension funds should pay the price.

Nevertheless, the differences between China and Germany are far more substantial than the similarities – not least in terms of how they put their surpluses to use. Lumping all surplus countries together – or all deficit countries, for that matter, will not help us find a way to rebalance the world economy.

Heleen Mees is a researcher at the Erasmus School of Economics in Rotterdam. Her book Between Greed and Desire – The World between Wall Street and Main Street was published in the Netherlands in 2009.

Copyright: Project Syndicate, 2010.www.project-syndicate.org

Shopping24

Da non perdere

Per l'Italia la carta del mondo

Mentre la crisi reale morde più crudelmente, mentre i mercati finanziari saggiano possibili

In Europa la carta «interna»

Batti e ribatti sui nudi sacrifici degli altri, sull'algido rigore senza paracadute e prima o poi

La commedia di Bruxelles

Al Parlamento europeo è andato in scena il terzo atto di una commedia dal titolo: Regole per le

Guarguaglini: ecco le mie verità

«Ho sempre detto che ero innocente, le conclusioni delle indagini lo dimostrano: nell'archiviazione

Una redistribuzione di buon senso

Arrivano dal ministero della Giustizia le nuove piante organiche dei tribunali. Un intervento

Casa, la banca non ti dà il mutuo? Allora meglio un affitto con riscatto. Come funziona

Il mercato dei mutui in Italia resta al palo. Nell'ultimo mese la domanda di prestiti ipotecari è


Jeff Bezos primo nella classifica di Fortune «businessperson of the year»

Dai libri alla nuvola informatica: Jeff Bezos, fondatore e amministratore delegato di Amazon,

Iron Dome, come funziona il sistema antimissile israeliano che sta salvando Tel Aviv

Gli sporadici lanci di razzi iraniani Fajr-5 contro Gerusalemme e Tel Aviv costituiscono una

Dagli Assiri all'asteroide gigante del 21/12/2012, storia di tutte le bufale sulla fine del mondo

Fine Del Mondo, Armageddon, end of the World, Apocalypse? Sembrerebbe a prima vista roba da